Somaliland: The deceptive widow in a Horn of Africa

By Olivia Rutazibwa

In a violent Horn of Africa, Somaliland is an oasis of relations still and order. Twenty years ago Somaliland announced itself independent. Since, however, no nation has famous this small state in a northeast of Somalia.

Broad, somewhat tilted streets in a whitewashed city. A variety of donkeys, H2O tanks, qat stands, goats, camels, people, jeeps, buses, taxis and uncountable shops. Hargeisa, a collateral of Somaliland is during a two-hours expostulate from a Ethiopian border. ‘In 1991 ninety percent of Hargeisa was destroyed. Four years after it was totally rebuilt’, says Lady Edna, who has a tough time stealing her pride. ‘So, we merit to be independent.’

We are in Edna’s office, in a sanatorium that has her name given she is a one who determined it. Besides being a apportion of unfamiliar affairs, Edna Adan Ismail was also a former First Lady of Somaliland. She was a mother of a “father of Somaliland”, a late boss Mohamed H. Ibrahim Egal (1993-2002). This year Lady Edna becomes 75, yet that does not stop her to daily run her women’s sanatorium with a lot of appetite and to disciple a independency of Somaliland. Edna: ‘The general village should be beholden that there is during slightest one protected breakwater in a region.’

Fans and allies

Twenty years after a stipulation of autonomy Somaliland has still not gained general recognition. ‘Just one nation should hang out a neck’, says Ayanle S. Derie, a deputy of Somaliland in a Ethiopian capital, Addis Abeba. He hopes he will one day see Somaliland recognized. Yet, he should not count on Ethiopia even yet it is one of Somaliland’s many sincere allies. ‘We do not meddle with domestic issues’, says a consul of Ethiopia in Hargeisa. He is unequivocally straightforward: ‘We are here given we have interests in Somaliland –access to a Somaliland seaport of Berbera– yet also given we share enemies – namely Al-Shabaab.’

This Islamist organization that is handling in Somalia is suspected of a explosve dispute of 29 Oct 2008 opposite a Ethiopian consulate in Hargeisa. Fear is still discernible today. From a outward zero tells we we are in a Ethiopian representation. And we have been interviewed entirely prolonged before we reached a building. we had to leave my mobile phone with a warden.

Western fans of Somaliland –like Great Britain, Scandinavian countries, a EU and a United States– indeed have a double routine on Somalia and Somaliland, even yet they strictly still disciple a singular Somalia. ‘The approval of Somaliland is an African matter’, is a summary we hear from that side. The African Union (AU) on a other palm is unequivocally formal: ‘The Cairo Summit of 1964 stipulated that borders contingency be reputable after decolonisation’, says an AU officer in Addis Abeba. ‘If we recognize Somaliland, where will this lead us? There are so many other regions in Somalia and Africa – even within Somaliland– that wish to secede.’

Somalia no more

The AU binds on to a assimilated Somalia, not in a slightest given – like a rest of a general village – it is itself investing resources and crew in a troops goal in executive and southern Somalia (AMISOM). When all is pronounced and done, a AU has a Somalis do a job. ‘The AU is a member state organisation, like a EU. So, in a approach Somalia is a boss’, says an AMISOM staff member whom we accommodate in a collateral of Kenya, Nairobi. ‘When a Somalis establish that Somaliland can secede, there is no problem for us’, says an AU officer in Addis.

In Somaliland they are not tender by such arguments. ‘Whom should we negotiate with about this matter?’ asks Boobe Yusuf Duale, a maestro of a separatist Somali National Movement. ‘With Puntland? With Al Shabaab? With boss Sheikh Sharif and a Transitional Federal Government? There is no instance that represents all Somalis to that we can turn.’ Lady Edna is even sharper: ‘Somaliland is a domestic widow of a nation that does not exist anymore. Somalia that everybody is articulate about is dead. Asking to negotiate autonomy with Somalia, is like seeking a widow to wait for her passed father to come behind to have him pointer a divorce papers.’

On a own

Somalilanders have not been refrained by a miss of general recognition. On a contrary, in a singular review between a needs of a internal race and a enterprise for general recognition, Somalilanders have successfully worked for assent and settlement for a final twenty years. They also privileged mines and disarmed militias. With a assistance of Somalilanders in a diaspora they were means to settle a lush private section and a multi-party system.

The story goes that Somaliland has achieved all of this on a own, yet any general assistance. ‘In a commencement a general village stayed aloof. It believed no fast domestic routine was probable in such a violent region’, says Dr. Aden Abokor about a early theatre of a democratisation routine during a spin of a century. ‘Moreover, it had already upheld a Transitional Federal Government elsewhere in Somalia.’

In Hargeisa, Abokor was a long-time conduct of Progressio, a EU-financed NGO, that had been strongly concerned in elections in Somaliland from a beginning. The initial elections were internal initiatives and were roughly totally financed by a Somalilanders themselves. Now, a general village finances elections for roughly 75 percent.

‘The thought they have finished all themselves, is a myth, adult to a certain degree’, says many a westerner when asked about it. ‘The settlement and assent routine underneath a Somali National Movement and a elders in a nineties was unequivocally something they devised themselves’, says a EU staff member in Nairobi. A European researcher in Hargeisa adds his possess remarks: ‘In a interloper camps, during a finish of a eighties and early in a nineties Somalilanders could minister financially to a Somali National Movement given a general village supposing in their needs. Today, that parable does not request anymore.’

When we expostulate around Hargeisa today, we positively do not have a sense that a pursuit is finished yet any unfamiliar assistance. Along a highway we see signboards of general organisations. At a university of Hargeisa any building is sponsored by a inexhaustible donor.

‘Somalilanders are unapproachable of not receiving bill support, yet per capita there is some-more income going to Somaliland than to a rest of Somalia’, says a EU officer in Hargeisa. ‘That is given projects here, distinct elsewhere in Somalia, can effectively be implemented.’ This conditions does meant that many organisations conduct budgets that are incomparable than a bill of a government. This means a state contingency be weak, given a private section and charitable organization yield basement comforts and services such as health caring and telecommunication.

In Somaliland alone there are allegedly some 3 hundred general organisations registered. International staff mostly lives in Nairobi, in Kenya. ‘Somaliland is deliberate a position in a riskful area’, says Lady Edna with a required indignation. ‘But Hargeisa is safer than Nairobi.’ The EU officer admits it is tough to coordinate and take well-informed decisions about Somaliland with staff operative from Nairobi. Moreover, many resources are mislaid and do not finish adult with a race for that they were meant.

Mohamed F. Hersi, democratisation dilettante for a Academy for Peace and Development (APD) in Hargeisa: ‘There is a change in a routine of a general community. They come here some-more often, yet a income does still not find a approach to Somalilanders.’ Hersi puts total on a income wasted: ‘Of any dual million usually 3 hundred thousands effectively strech people.’

A code of democracy of their own

‘We are propitious that a general village leaves us aside’, says Boobe, a maestro of a Somali National Movement and a vice-president of APD. ‘We competence have finished adult in a awful conditions of a brothers in a south.’ His colleague, Mohamed Hersi agrees: ‘When people are left alone, they can mind their possess business.’ Such relations leisure has already achieved one engaging outcome for Somaliland’s democratisation process: a complicated executive administration with normal elements of governing.

‘Somalis are a people of nomads and always understanding with conflicts and problems by residence elders. Historically, they have gathere Asking Somaliland to negotiate autonomy with Somalia, is like seeking a widow to wait for her passed father to come behind to have him pointer a divorce papers d on a arise of Guurti to intercede and discharge justice’, says Abdillahi Ibrahim Habane. During a assent routine in a nineties a elders played such an critical purpose in settlement that it was motionless to embody a Guurti complement henceforth in inhabitant politics. ‘So, we now have a Parliament with dual Chambers: a reduce residence with 82 directly inaugurated member and an top residence (Guurti) with 82 elders that are allocated by a several clans.’

Abdillahi is a secretary-general of a Guurti and welcomes me in a Upper House during a heart of Hargeisa. ‘All law proposals, solely those on budgets, contingency be authorized by a Guurti.’ It means a Guurti is a unequivocally absolute body. Many explain it has turn politicised in a march of a years. So, some wish to examination a charge and a approach a members are appointed. Few wish to do divided with it though.

Also a Guurti itself sees a significance of reforms. ‘We contingency go along with a times, yet we contingency find something that suits a society’, says Abdillahi. Through their members they deliberate people in several regions about a issue. In a eyes of Abdillahi there is no doubt of democratically electing a 82 elders or of permitting women to a Guurti. ‘Currently, there is one lady in a Guurti, given she hereditary a position from her husband, yet it is opposite a tradition.’

A male who overhears a review laughs during this and contradicts Adillahi, who is not tender and continues: ‘if we directly elect a Guurti, what would a disproportion be with a Lower House? These elders are not usually picked adult from a street, we know. In a regions, people assemble to plead whom they will nominee – we can review it to an American electoral college.’ And he pleasantly refers a women to a Lower House.

Regardless of a purpose of traditions in a executive state, a whole democratisation routine especially stays a business of a elite. ‘Somaliland has never had a clever executive state and a assent routine in fact was initial and inaugural a amicable reconciliation, that did not indispensably go opposite a state structures,’ says Abdullahi M. Odowa, executive of a Institute for Peace and Conflict Studies during a University of Hargeisa. ‘Today this is a means for dispute in society. Up to a top level, people do not know how a complement functions. They go and quarrel to discharge a jobs between opposite clans.’

Pay Cash or Seed?

The durability change of a residence and family complement can be gifted during a many astonishing moments, also in a city. Hibo M. Khayre, who works for APD tells me about Seed, an sms compensate service. In a nation yet a bank and bankcard complement where a banking is value so small that people lift wads of bank notes, alternatives are some-more than welcome. Hibo: ‘Even H2O sellers who go adult and down a streets with their dickey carts will ask you: “Cash or Zaad?”‘

Besides payments in shops, Somalilanders also send income to any other around Seed. ‘That creates it even easier to ask family members for money. Just send a elementary sms to ask for 5 or 10 euros; and we can’t fake we haven’t seen it.’ Zaad is also used to get a date: ‘When a child wants to go out with we and we refuse, he will send we some income around Zaad, “to buy something nice”.’

Once she sent income to a wrong person. When she asked it back, she got it back. ‘People know any other here. There is always a possibility a commission of my family will go over to his to transparent out matters. People cite to equivocate that.’ And what about unchanging courts of probity then? ‘These usually work when matters can’t be staid by a families. Justice takes a prolonged time and it is expensive. Besides, again a family would put down a income and get me a lawyer.’

It seems like there are several together universes in today’s Somaliland. A star of residence elders and family ties that organize and establish amicable life. The star of a diaspora that put income and new ideas in a country. The star of general organisations and elections that seem to be somewhere in-between.

For an alien it stays misleading how these universes accurately fit with any other or in what instruction traditions will evolve. The answer is substantially in what both Hibo and her co-worker Nasir Osman tell me about a dual vital hotels in Hargeisa: a Mansoor Hotel in a northwest and a Ambassador Hotel during a airfield in a south of a city. Both accommodate unequivocally despotic reserve standards that fit a continual upsurge of general assist workers, politicians and consultants. Both were built by Somalilanders from a diaspora.

Nasir: ‘When Mansoor non-stop a doors there were tensions. People pronounced a city was out of balance. You see, any residence has a possess section in a city. When a Ambassador Hotel, that is owned by a opposite clan, was built years later, a residence elders pronounced things were right. The city was in change again during last.’

Somaliland for dummies
•Surface 137,600 km² (or about 4 times Belgium)

•Coastline 850 km

•Population 3.85 million (the general village puts a measure during usually dual million)

•Capital Hargeisa (680,000 inhabitants)

•Economy 60-65% cattle (goats, sheep, camels, cows) and 20% cultivation for domestic use. Other vital sources of income: unfamiliar assistance and remittances from a diaspora.

(Source: Somaliland in Figures 2011, Ministry of Planning)

Before independence

Until 1960 Somaliland was a British dependency while a rest of today’s Somalia was a cluster of Italy. After 5 days of autonomy Somaliland willingly assimilated a rest of Somalia on 1 Jul 1960. For Somalilanders from day one this was deliberate a initial step in a instruction of a Greater Somalia dream: bringing together a 5 Somali regions that had been separate by colonisation. In a seventies it became apparent yet that a Somali star would never be reunited. After all, Somalis in a northeast of Kenya were enclosed in Kenya on autonomy in 1963. Also a race of a French-Somali Coast chose for autonomy in 1977 and determined a state of Djibouti. The Somali-Ethiopian fight of 1977-78 was won by Ethiopia and a Ogaden segment remained partial of Ethiopia.

Meanwhile Siad Barre organized a troops manoeuvre in a Republic of Somalia in 1969 and incited a nation into a revolutionary Somali Democratic Republic. Somalilanders were frequency represented in a executive supervision in Mogadishu. In their possess segment they suffered from taste and tellurian right abuses. So, many fled a country. In 1981, a Somali National Movement was founded in London. From their home bottom in interloper camps in Ethiopia in a eighties this transformation jointly with other Somali insurgent movements conducted a riotous fight opposite Siad Barre. In 1988, a dispute became a genuine polite fight and Somaliland cities like Hargeisa were bombed. In 1991, when Siad Barre was suspended from energy 100,000 people had died in a conflict.

In Mogadishu a insurgent movements fought a extreme energy battle. The Somali National Movement withdrew to Somaliland and on 18 May 1991 announced a autonomy of a Somaliland Republic. (or)

Key to fortitude in Somaliland

These are a few reasons because Somaliland is fast since this does not seem to attain in Somalia:

■ Somaliland was a dependency and not a colony. Social structures remained intact.

■ Somaliland, distinct a south of Somalia, has a rather comparable residence structure. There is one categorical residence (Isaaq) and a few smaller ones beside.

■ The Somali National Movement was a genuine people’s movement. Men and resources depended on a clans, so a transformation was hold accountable by a clans. After ransom a transformation eliminated power.

■ After 1991, a Isaaq residence did not take punish on a clans that were on a side of Siad Barre.

■ The assent conferences were an beginning of and paid with a income of a Somalilanders themselves.

This essay was done probable by a financial support of a Fund for Scientific Research and is partial of Olivia Rutazibwa’s PhD investigate on a democratisation routine in Somaliland.

Author:Olivia Rutazibwa.

Source:  EthioSun. The Independent Voice.


Tags: , , , , , ,

About Balishire